Band Rehearsal Companion

How to practise with a metronome without hating it

· 7 min read

Almost every musician has the same first experience with a metronome. You switch it on, start playing, and within four bars it feels like the click is wrong. It is speeding up. It is dragging. It is somehow off. You turn it off, play the passage again, and it feels fine.

The click was not wrong. It was the first honest feedback your timing has had, and it is uncomfortable. The good news is that the discomfort goes away quickly with the right exercises, and what replaces it is the single most useful skill in a band: being able to hold a tempo without thinking about it.

Why the click feels wrong

Without a reference, your tempo moves with the music. You speed up on the easy bits and slow down on the hard ones, because your hands are setting the pace instead of the other way round. It sounds fine to you, because you are moving with yourself.

A metronome does not move. The moment your tempo drifts, you hear the gap, and because you were not expecting one, it sounds like the click's fault. Give it a week of short sessions and the gap starts to feel like information instead of an accusation.

Set it up so it helps

Start slower than you think. The metronome is not for proving you can play the song at full speed. Set it where the passage is easy, then build up. The same tempo ladder that works for learning a passage works here: clean repetitions, then a few BPM faster. The detail is in practising a song at home with an A/B loop.

Make the click loud enough to hear over yourself. A click you cannot hear when you play loud is a click you will ignore in exactly the bars that need it. Headphones help for drummers and anyone with an amp.

Choose a sound you can live with. A sharp, short click is easier to lock to than a soft beep. If the sound annoys you after ten minutes, change it; you will not practise with something you hate.

Accent the first beat of the bar. It keeps you from losing your place and turns the click into a bar instead of an endless row of identical beats.

Five exercises that build timing

  1. Play right on the click until it disappears. When you are exactly with it, the click is masked by your own note and seems to vanish. That is the target. If you can hear the click clearly, you are early or late.
  2. Click on two and four. Set the metronome to half the tempo and treat each click as beats two and four, where the snare falls. This is how the groove of most pop and rock feels, and it forces you to keep beats one and three yourself.
  3. Slow everything right down. Play a passage at 50 or 60 BPM. Slow is harder than fast, because there is more time between clicks for your tempo to wander. Ten minutes of this does more for timing than an hour at full speed.
  4. Count out loud. While you play, count "one, two, three, four" aloud. It feels silly. It also shows you instantly where you lose the bar, which is usually exactly where the part gets difficult.
  5. Play the transitions, not the songs. Most tempo problems happen between sections: into the chorus, out of the solo, after a break. Loop the last bar of one section and the first bar of the next with the click on.

A sixth, once these feel natural: turn the click off for a few bars and back on, and see whether you are still with it when it returns. Some metronomes do this for you with silent bars; with others, a volume knob and some honesty work too.

Practising with the whole band

A band can use a click in rehearsal in two ways, and both are worth trying.

The drummer on headphones. Only the drummer hears the click, and everyone else follows the drummer. This is how most bands that play live with a click do it, and it means the rest of the band practises following a steady drummer, which is the job.

Everyone hears it, for new material. When the band is learning a new song, a click everyone can hear stops the tempo creeping up rehearsal after rehearsal and makes it obvious who is pushing and who is dragging. Turn it off once the song holds, and record the run without the click to check it did not run away.

Either way, agree the tempo first and write it on the song. Finding the right number, and checking afterwards whether the band really plays at it, is covered in how to find the BPM of a song.

How Band Companion's metronome works

Band Companion is an app for bands to record rehearsals and practise, and its metronome is built around the song rather than around the app:

What it does not do today: there are no silent bars and no subdivisions to choose from. For the silent-bar exercise, use the volume.

Frequently asked questions

Why does the metronome feel like it is speeding up or slowing down?

Because your own tempo is moving and the metronome is not. Without a reference, players speed up on easy passages and slow down on hard ones without noticing. The click makes that drift audible for the first time, and at first it sounds like the click is wrong.

What tempo should I start practising at?

At the tempo where the passage is genuinely easy, without having to concentrate hard. That is usually much slower than the final tempo. Play it cleanly several times, then raise the metronome by a few BPM and repeat.

Should I practise with a metronome all the time?

No. Use it to build and check timing, then also practise without it, because in a band you follow other people, not a click. A good routine alternates: a passage with the click, then the same passage without it, then with it again to check you have not drifted.

Should the whole band use a click in rehearsal?

It helps with new songs, to stop the tempo creeping up and to show who is rushing. For songs the band already knows, a common setup is that only the drummer hears the click and everyone follows the drummer. Record the rehearsal to check whether the tempo holds once the click is off.

What is the best way to set a metronome for a band song?

Agree the tempo and time signature with the band, write them on the song, and have everyone use the same numbers. In Band Companion the metronome opens from the song already set to its tempo and time signature, so nobody has to remember them.

Your band’s rehearsals, in one place

Record, organise and practise. Free up to 200 MB per band.

Open it in your browser

Or install the app: