Band Rehearsal Companion

How to write a song as a band without losing the ideas

· 8 min read

At the end of rehearsal, the guitarist plays a riff nobody has heard before. It works. The drummer comes in, the bass finds a line, and for five minutes it sounds like a song. Someone records it on their phone and drops it in the group chat.

Three weeks later, nobody can find the recording. What you play now is close, but the bridge everyone loved that night has gone and nobody quite remembers how it went. The lyrics are in a note on the singer's phone, in a version the rest of the band has never seen.

Bands don't run short of ideas. Half-finished songs die of disorder: ideas scattered everywhere, versions that overwrite each other in your memory, and decisions made in the rehearsal room that are forgotten on the way out. It doesn't have to go that way. Below is a way to work up a new song as a band so the ideas stay put, and how we recommend doing it with Band Companion.

Why half-finished songs get lost

Ideas turn up at any time and anywhere. A melody hummed into a phone at two in the morning, a riff at the end of rehearsal, a line of lyrics typed on the bus. Each one ends up somewhere different: one person's camera roll, the group chat, someone else's notes app.

Versions overwrite each other. A new song changes every week. If you only remember the latest version, you can't tell whether what you changed made it better. "We played it differently last week and I think it was better" goes nowhere without last week's recording.

Decisions don't get written down. "Only one chorus", "bass comes in on the second time round", "better in A than in G". It is decided in ten seconds, everyone agrees, and by the following Thursday each of you remembers something different.

Only one person has the real lyrics. The words live on the writer's phone and everyone else knows them by ear, so nobody can suggest anything about a line they have never seen written down.

One place per song, from day one

The fix is simple and hard to keep up: every idea that might become a song gets its own place from the very first moment, even if all it has is a working title like "March riff". Everything to do with it goes there: the audio of the idea, every run-through you record, the lyrics, the notes.

The working title matters. If you wait until the idea "is a song" before giving it a home, the first few weeks, which is when everything happens, end up scattered across the chat.

Record every version, not just the good one

While you are working on a new song, record every run-through at rehearsal, the bad ones too. Not so you can listen to all of them, but so you can put today's version next to last month's when someone says it used to be better.

With the versions filed by date under the same song, the conversation changes: you stop remembering and start listening. Quite often the old bridge really was better, and you can get it back because it is still there. How to record rehearsals without effort: how to record band rehearsals on your phone.

Write decisions down where they happen

A decision about the arrangement makes more sense attached to the moment of the recording it describes. "Shorter chorus here" at 1:40 on Tuesday's take is worth more than a paragraph in the chat saying "shorter chorus". Anyone who missed rehearsal gets it by listening for ten seconds.

Decisions that don't belong to a moment, like the key, the tempo or who sings what, go in a note on the same song, with the date: "12 March: A major, 96 BPM". When someone asks in two months why you play it in A, the answer will be there.

A way of working up a new song

This is what we recommend, rehearsal by rehearsal:

  1. The rehearsal where the idea is born: play it for a few minutes without judging it, and record it. Create the song with a working title and put the audio in it that same day.
  2. Between rehearsals: everyone listens to the recording and leaves marks where they have an idea or a doubt ("a bridge could go here", "riff an octave down?"). Whoever is writing the lyrics puts them in the song, even half-finished, so the others can read them.
  3. The next rehearsal: start with the marks. Try the options one at a time and record each attempt. At the end, listen to the best two and decide. Write down what you decided.
  4. Repeat until the song stops changing from one week to the next. Then mark the good version as the final one: it is the one everyone will use to learn it at home.

A new song isn't finished in one rehearsal. With this cycle, each rehearsal picks up where the last one left off instead of starting over.

How we recommend doing it with Band Companion

Band Companion is not a recording studio: it is the place where the band keeps its songs, its takes and what it decides about each one. For a new song, this is how we would do it.

What it doesn't do, so there are no surprises: it is not a DAW, so it doesn't record on separate tracks, overdub or mix. It doesn't keep a history of lyrics or notes: if someone rewrites them, the previous text is gone, so it is worth copying a version you like into a dated note before changing it. There is no chat and no comments on takes, only on links. And imported audio gets the date you import it, not the date it was recorded, so if you import an old idea, put the date in the name.

Frequently asked questions

How do you write a song as a band?

Usually someone brings an idea (a riff, a melody, some lyrics) and the band develops it by playing it. What makes it work is recording every version, writing down what gets decided, and starting each rehearsal from where the last one left off.

Where should we keep musical ideas so they don't get lost?

In one place per song, shared with the whole band, from day one and with a working title. A chat doesn't work: ideas get mixed up with everything else and you can't find any of them two weeks later.

How do we choose between two versions of a song?

Record both on the same day, in the same conditions, and listen to them back to back. Deciding from memory favours whichever you played last, or whoever argues hardest.

Who should write the lyrics in a band?

Whoever wants to, but they need to be visible to everyone while they are being written. Lyrics only the singer knows can't be improved by anyone else, and the band can't shape the music around lines that are still to come.

Do you need to read music to write songs as a band?

No. Most bands write by ear, and the recording does the job of the score: it is the record of what was decided. If someone writes out chords or notation, great, but it isn't essential.

Your band’s rehearsals, in one place

Record, organise and practise. Free up to 200 MB per band.

Open it in your browser

Or install the app: