Band Rehearsal Companion

How to run a band rehearsal that moves the songs forward

· 7 min read

Most band rehearsals go the same way. Someone is twenty minutes late. You play the songs you already know, because they are fun and everyone is warming up. Halfway through, the new song comes out, it falls apart at the bridge, and the next fifteen minutes are four people explaining to each other what they think happened. You run it once more, it is slightly better, and the room booking ends.

Next week, nobody quite remembers what was agreed about the bridge.

None of that is a lack of talent or effort. It is a lack of a plan, and of a record. A rehearsal that moves the songs forward has three parts: what you decide before you arrive, how you spend the time in the room, and what you do in the ten minutes after. The middle part is the one everybody thinks about. The other two are where most of the progress comes from.

Before you arrive, decide what the rehearsal is for

One main goal per rehearsal. "Get the new song to the end without stopping." "Fix the transitions in the first half of the set." "Run the whole set once at gig tempo." A rehearsal that tries to do everything does nothing in particular, and you leave without knowing whether it went well.

Write the running order down and share it before the day. Which songs, in what order, roughly how long on each. It sounds bureaucratic for a group of friends. It saves the first twenty minutes of every rehearsal, the ones spent deciding what to play while someone tunes.

Put the hard work early. Concentration is highest in the first hour. Play one song you know to warm up, then go straight to the new or broken one. The songs you can already play are the reward at the end, not the padding at the start.

Everyone does their homework on their own time. Rehearsal is for the things you can only do together: the feel, the transitions, the dynamics, who comes in when. Learning your part is not one of them. If the guitarist is working out the chords in the room, four people are waiting for one.

That homework is much easier when everybody has the same reference: the band's own recording of the song, not the record. More on that below.

In the room, play more and talk less

Record everything. Not to release, to remember. Put a phone in the middle of the room and record each run of each song. It costs nothing and it settles every argument that starts with "I think we were rushing". How to make that painless, and keep the takes filed by song instead of lost in a camera roll, is in how to record band rehearsals on your phone.

When something goes wrong, play it again before discussing it. The first instinct is to stop and talk. Most problems sort themselves out on the second attempt, and the ones that do not become obvious: it is always the same place, and usually the same person. Then talk, briefly, about that one spot.

Work in sections, not whole songs. If the bridge is the problem, play the last line of the chorus into the bridge and out into the next verse, five times. Running the whole song to get to the bridge costs three minutes per attempt and wears everybody out.

Use a click for the new material. A metronome at the tempo the band agreed is the fastest way to find out who is pushing and who is dragging, and it stops the tempo creeping up rehearsal after rehearsal. Turn it off once the song holds.

Mark the moments as they happen. "That ending was great." "Bass comes in a bar early here." Said out loud and forgotten by the car park. Said into a marker on the recording, it is still there next week.

Leave the last fifteen minutes to play through. At least once per rehearsal, run songs end to end without stopping, in the order you would play them live. Stopping to fix things is practice. Not stopping is rehearsal for the gig, and it is a different skill.

Ten minutes afterwards that make the next rehearsal better

This is the part almost no band does, and it is where a rehearsal turns into progress instead of a pleasant evening.

  1. Listen to the takes of the song you worked on. Not all of them. The last one or two runs. It takes ten minutes and you will hear things nobody noticed while playing.
  2. Decide which take is the version. When the band agrees on an arrangement, mark that take as the reference. It is what everybody practises over until the next change.
  3. Write down what changed. The cut second solo, the new ending, the chorus a tone lower. One line each, attached to the song, not to someone's memory of a Tuesday.
  4. Give everybody one thing to fix. Specific and small. "The fill into the last chorus." Homework that fits in one sentence gets done.
  5. Set the goal for the next rehearsal. It is usually obvious once you have listened back.

Practising at home is then concrete: open the reference take, go to the marker, loop the passage. The technique is in practising a song at home with an A/B loop, and for practising your part over the band, in a backing track player for practice.

How Band Companion fits into this

Band Companion is an app built for exactly this cycle: plan, rehearse, listen back, practise. What it does today:

What it does not do: it does not schedule rehearsals or track who is coming (the calendar is for gigs), and there is no chat. It is the band's songs and recordings in one place, not a replacement for the group message.

Frequently asked questions

How long should a band rehearsal be?

Two to three hours is the usual range for a band that rehearses weekly. Concentration drops after about two hours, so put the hard material in the first hour and keep the end for running songs straight through. A shorter rehearsal with one clear goal beats a longer one without a plan.

How do you structure a band rehearsal?

A short warm-up with a song you know, the main goal of the day while everyone is fresh, work in sections on the parts that break, and a run-through of several songs without stopping at the end. Agree the order before the day so nobody spends the first twenty minutes deciding what to play.

Should we record our band rehearsals?

Yes. A phone in the middle of the room is enough. Recordings settle disagreements about tempo and feel, let everyone hear what the band actually sounds like, and give you a reference version of each song to practise over at home. The key is to keep them filed by song so you can find them later.

What should each band member do between rehearsals?

Learn their own part, using the band's reference recording rather than the original record, and work on the one specific thing that came up at the last rehearsal. Rehearsal time is for what you can only do together, not for learning notes.

How do you stop rehearsals turning into long discussions?

Play the passage again before discussing it. Most problems disappear on the second attempt, and the ones that remain are easier to pin down. When you do talk, talk about one spot, and listen to the recording if there is disagreement about what happened.

Your band’s rehearsals, in one place

Record, organise and practise. Free up to 200 MB per band.

Open it in your browser

Or install the app: